I feel like this book wasn't as good as the first three, but was still pretty good. One of my favorite cats died and that was just really tragic. I wanted to cry. But I understand why it was done, to further the story. Goodbye cat I loved that I don't want to say the name of because I don't want to give it away. On a happier note: I am still a Sandstorm and Fireheart shipper. GRAYSTRIPE WHY. Sorry for my outburst. This book does have an end that, while completely expected, will still leave you with your heart pounding. Why are you not reading this book yet? Pick up this series. Totally worth the two hours you'll spend on each book.